Mother’s Day in Prison

Many wonderful articles are appearing about mothers in prison as we approach this Mother’s Day, May 11th.

mothersinprisonPhoto courtesy of www.carbonatedtv.com

m4_13052012

 

 

 

___________________________________________________________________

Nancy Mullane, on the blog she co-founded, The Life of the Law, interviews
Veronica Martinez at Folsom Women’s Prison in California, which you can listen to or read to see how she was shackled during birth and had to give up her baby after three days—luckily to her family; but Martinez also points out the amazing support of the other women in the jail where she was at the time:

“My bunkie had a collage of babies pasted. She had pasted it with toothpaste, cause that’s what we used. In the county jail, you don’t have tape or glue or any of that so she took toothpaste and she pasted all these pictures of cutout magazines and baby feet and babies and stuff. And she made a little sign, ‘It’s a Girl’ on my bunk.” Martinez, like so many women echoed this sentiment about the cohort of women behind bars: “Everybody comes together in stuff like that cause women, we do understand. It’s not an easy thing to just give up your baby like that.”

Rachel Roth, activist and reproduction rights expert, wrote on the blog, Mom’s Rising, “Just in Time for Mother’s Day, Minnesota Bill Against Shackling Pregnant Women Heads to Governor.” Roth pointed out that Minnesota becomes one of nineteen states that now have “some type of statute limiting the situations in which a pregnant woman can be shackled.”

Deborah Jiang Stein who was born in prison to a pregnant incarcerated and addicted mother wrote her story in Prison Baby. She knows first-hand how, instead of prison, addicted mothers need “family support, community health care, wellness alternatives, and access to community resources,” for what Jiang Stein calls “a positive path to wholeness, health and full citizenship.” She presents facts on her website The unPrison Project, and they are compelling, although she doesn’t site where the stats come from. While I have heard 70-80%, she says that 85% of women in prison are mothers. She also says that

  • “2.3 million minor children, or 3% of all children in the U.S., have a parent in prison; most under age 10.”

From my research, when I wrote about holidays behind bars for Boston Magazine, I thought how sad it is that children must manage when parents are incarcerated, which according to Pew Research Study is not as rare as you might think: one in 28 kids has a parent in prison, nationwide.

Andrea James, now Executive Director of Families for Justice as Healing, wrote what it was like to leave small children and go to jail in her book Upper Bunkies Unite: And Other Thoughts On the Politics of Mass Incarceration. In a recent article on Huffington Post, James made the point that the so-called War on Drugs is responsible for separating so many non-violent women from their children, clearly calling for other ways to deal with behavior that needs “correcting.” Victoria Law also wrote about Families in her article for Waging Non-Violence, and brought up that the group of incarcerated and formerly incarcerated women is organizing a FREE HER rally in Washington, D.C. on June 21st, an idea that emerged while James was serving time. Per James: “We wanted to have a huge public event to raise our voices and raise awareness of all the women inside who are separated from their families and their communities… We also want to let the legislative and executive branches know that people are paying attention. These are people we care about.”

In my experience teaching at Framingham, I remember Mother’s Day in prison and the heartbreak of women having to see their children in the Visiting Room for a few hours, or the more poignant heartbreak of their children not being able to get transportation to the one state prison for women in Massachusetts. The connection was so strong between mother and child that even time and distance could not, in most cases, sever that bond.

One of the most touching experiences I had around that issue was when we produced plays in prison. We taped the play—these were home videos, mind you, always with a see-saw effect of an amateur holding camera, but generously filmed by a dear soul in the Education department at the prison who believed as I do in theatre as transformation. We then sent these tapes home to the families of the woman so they could be proud of their work—in perpetuity. I began a tradition of allowing each participant to have a few moments on tape to talk to her mother, father, grandparents, lover, or to her children. The women would tell their kids “If Mami can do this, then you can too,” or “See, Mommy is in school, just like you!”

The women looked forward to these video moments. They were so simple but so important, and ultimately, when they received letters back or talked to their family during coveted phone time, they shared with me how proud they were that their parents and their kids were proud of them. This is not to say that they should have been in prison, but that they did something to make use of their best selves while they were there.

On Mother’s Day, I remember my mother who died while I was teaching in prison, and the amazing comfort my prisoner-students gave me when I went behind bars to teach. On Mother’s Day, I also remember Bertie who somehow killed her baby and lived with that gruesome truth torturing her all her life. I honor Dolly, the heart and soul of my theatre program at Framingham. Dolly lost her mother when she was behind bars and could not go to the funeral; she lost her grand-daughter too who was brutally murdered. And while she suffered the losses and the stinging pain of being away from her family during those funerals, she received as much comfort as possible from the women. Just as Martinez says, the community knows what it is to bear such tragedies. And they know too what it is to see pure joy in the eyes of a child.
This Mother’s Day, honor women behind bars by educating yourself about the Free Marissa Campaign. Per The Nation,Activists launched a Mother’s Day “Week of Action” campaign on Friday to support Marissa Alexander, the Florida woman facing sixty years in prison for firing warning shots to ward off her abusive husband.” Alexander is a mother of two teenage twins and a 3-year-old daughter, and she will spend this holiday under house arrest. The campaign runs May 9-May 18 and you can find out more here.
Mothers Day Inmates

 

 

 

Scenes from the State House

Following up on Jobs Not Jails successful rally on Saturday, April 26th, more than seventy volunteers showed up today, April 30th, at the Massachusetts State House to hold orange banners, filled with petitions with more than 46,000 names—ironic since that’s about what it costs per year per state prisoner in Massachusetts. With the rally cry “Jobs Not Jails,” volunteers greeted passer-bys and legislators who stopped by to pledge their support. Here are some scenes from today.

JNJ1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Members of Jobs Not Jails in front of the State House including Steve O’Neill (left) and other members of Ex-Prisoners and Prisoners for Community Advancement (EPOCA).

Rep.Sen.JNJ

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Senator James Eldrige (Acton) on the left and Rep. Tom Sanncandro (Ashland) flank JNJ volunteers Lily Williams (left) and Brenda Dejarnette, both volunteers for Jobs Not Jails. Below Rep. Sannicandro signs the petition and a copy of the petition itself with what JNJ is standing for.

Rep Sannicandro signs the JNJ Petition

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

JNJ Petition

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Also at the rally was Jason Lydon of Black and Pink and Barb Dougan of Families Against Mandatory Minimums (right, second pic).

Jason

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Barb Dougan

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The day included other volunteers who showed up as well, holding signs, passing out water and taking photos.

Jarmahl

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jarmahl Crawford from Blackstonian.

Jobs Not Jails also reminded passer-bys and supporters to call their legislators and support bills that aim to stop mass incarceration. See my post below for more about the slate of criminal justice bills that are in process this year.

State House

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

More MA: Updated JNJ Schedule & CJ Hearings from State House

First, the updated schedule for Jobs Not Jails — tomorrow at the Boston Common, rain or shine, 1pm. Speakers are in bold. Issues in italics if no named speaker. Thanks to Lori Kenschaft for passing this along.

12:30  Music from the Second Line Brass Band
1:20    MC Cassandra Bensahih, Ex-Prisoners & Prisoners Org. Comm. Advancement
1:23    Sunni Ali,  Boston Workers Alliance,
1:27    Viraphanh Douangmany, Innocence Commission
1:31    Andrea James, Bail Reform
1:35    Ivan Richiez, Stop and Frisk
1:39    Donnelle Wright – Jobs Not Jails
1:43    Maura Healey, Candidate for Attorney General
1:48    Music from Antonio Ennis

****APRIL 30 LOBBYING PRIORITIES FOR JNJ:
2:00    Mandatory Minimums 
2:04    RMV Collateral Sanctions – EPOCA
2:08    Addiction FundingMassachusetts Org for Addiction Recovery

2:12    Music by Revolutionary Snake Ensemble
2:32    Keturah  Brewster, Youth Jobs Coalition
2:36    Manny Gines & Rocky Thompson, Carpenters’ Union on  Minimum wage
2:40    Cassandra Bensahih, CORI Reform
2:50    Larry Turner, math teacher and father of a murder victim
2:55    Warren Tolman, Candidate for Attorney General
3:00    Music by Tem Blessed
3:15    CeCe McDonald, activist/trans woman incarcerated in men’s prison
3:20    Rev. Paul Robeson Ford, Union Baptist Church
3:25    Shackling
3:30    Black and Latino Legislative Caucus speaker -kicks off April 30th Action
3:35    Music
****INSTRUCTIONS FOR APRIL 30th LOBBYING
jnj-paper-web2
__________________________________________________________________________

Yesterday, at the State House, three fantastic panels testified to the Judiciary Committee on issues that they would like to see addressed. While JNJ has certain legislative priorities, and is approaching lobbying in their own way, these panels were activism in action. People spoke eloquently about other bills, but the organization and effort put into these panel testimonies was most impressive.

FAMM or Families Against Mandatory Minimums led by Barb Dougan in Massachusetts spoke passionately to do away with mandatory minimum sentencing, represented by two bills, H1645 and H1646.Dougan said “Too many people go to prison,” and sentences “are not proportionate with criminal history.” Two recovering addicts talked about how they transformed their lives but that they could have begun much earlier if they had immediately had alternatives to mandatory sentencing. Both other panelists, Maryann Frangules from Massachusetts Organization for Addiction Recovery, and Jerry Madden, former Texas House Corrections Chairman and senior fellow at Right on Crime, rounded out the panel from very different ends of the spectrum: but both said drug treatment was the answer not incarceration.

photo (1)

Barb Dougan, center, flanked by panelists and members of FAMM, standing

A panel sponsored by the Pretrial Working Group (PWG) knocked it out of the park. It began with Lois Ahrens of the Real Cost of Prisons Project recommending elimation of money bail because of it not being a true determinant of dangerousness. As an alternative, she suggested statewide pretrial services and referrals to community based programs. Hope Haff of the National Association of Social Workers said the PWG was against  H1434 since it was about building a new jail for pretrial women: remaining in jail for two months caused loss of housing, custody, inability to pay rent and many other services. Additionally, Norma Wassel, Committee for Public Counsel, pointed out that a large scale study showed that those held in jail pretrial were four times more likely to be sentenced to jail and three times more likely to go to prison. Rachel Roth, reproductive justice scholar, pointed out the harm jails inflict on women’s health including “diet, risk of sexual assault, mental illness, and birthing issues.” She said, “Instead of building new jails we can reduce number of women in custody.” The expertise of all these women was quite wonderful.

Andrea James of Families for Justice and Healing was last, but certainly not least. She said as a “formerly incarerated woman, “I am often the missing seat at the table,” and immediately grabbed everyone’s attention. It cannot be emphasized enough, she added, that separating mothers from children causes grievous harm. She, along with the rest of the panel recommended community based health and treatment —not jail. Prison seldom rehabilitates,she said.

I don’t see us building more prisons in the near future, said Judiciary Committee Vice-Chair, Christopher Markey. That was a breath of really fresh air in a long afternoon in a hot room with little response from listeners—Not a criticism, it is their job to listen at this point before they make decisions. Let’s hope Markey can make sure the Legislature agrees!

The final panel that was an wonderful example of diverse voices speaking for a cause was on solitary confinement. The bill in question was H1486 and Attorney Bonnie Tenneriello at Prison Legal Services spoke eloquently on why adjustments to solitary are so needed in Massachusetts since as it is, without certain regulations, it is “bad for public safety.” Beth McGuire talked powerfully about her son held in solitary, very tortured by isolation: “I’m scared of being alone all the time…I really need some help…send me somewhere…I need something to occupy my time.” And most expertly, Kristin Dame, a former clinical coordinator from Cedar Junction testified on how infamous segregation confined people with no limitation, breeding violence. She said that being “deprived of human contact really can destroy a person,” and explained how in isolation, “People driven to self harm.” She recommended limiting solitary and incentives to help prisoners earn privileges such as time in the yard. Some important details of the bill: “Segregated housing should be for the briefest term and under the least restrictive conditions practicable….”

For anyone who wants to know about solitary confinement in the U.S., see Solitary Nation. Gruesome but eye-opening.

These panels were examples of how we must approach getting change, and examples of activism at its best. Let’s hope the continued momentum and added energy from Jobs Not Jails creates more people speaking out for justice.

Jobs Not Jails: Schedule and More!

One thing you gotta say for the Jobs Not Jails (JNJ) campaign is that they have created an amazingly strong organizing effort on the ground. And no matter how many people actually show up on April 26–hopefully thousands–they have done a great job educating people who might not have heard the word about mass incarceration.

On that day, from 1-4pm, activists, union organizers, students, religious groups, politicians, business folk, former prisoners, and those in recovery will head to the Boston Common Bandstand to rally for jobs instead of prison construction. Then on April 30, JNJ plans to ring round the State House orange banners with the names of some 25,000 who have signed on to stop prison building: each name standing for a vote against a new prison bed and a vote for job creation. That day they plan to lobby legislators for some of the criminal justice bills already on the table including ending mandatory minimum sentencing; ending collateral sanctions and fees regarding prison phone service and driver’s license suspension; reforming classification, levels of punishment, and parole; providing access to rehabilitative services; and shifting the system as a whole by reforming pretrial services and establishing restorative justice practices in Massachusetts.

JNJ has just announced a list of the speakers for the rally on April 26. Those items/names in bold below are confirmed, and those in italics include issues to be addressed, but names of speakers for those issues were not yet confirmed as of this post.

12:30

 

 

Music from the Second Line Brass Band

1:20

 

 

MC Cassandra Bensahih, EPOCA

1:23

 

 

Sunni Ali, Boston Workers Alliance

1:27

 

 

Stop & Frisk   

1:30

 

 

Phone Rates – Committee of Friends and Relatives of Prisoners

1:34

 

 

MUSIC

1:45

 

 

Shackling

1:55

 

 

Bail Reform

2:00

 

 

Mandatory Minimums

2:05

 

 

Addiction Funding – Massachusetts Org for Addiction Recovery

2:10

 

 

MUSIC from Revolutionary Snake Ensemble

2:30

 

 

RMV collateral sanctionsEPOCA

2:35

 

 

Keturah  Brewster, Youth Jobs Coalition

2:40

 

 

Minimum Wage

2:45

 

 

MUSIC from Revolutionary Snake Ensemble

2:55

 

 

CeCe McDonald, activist/trans woman incarcerated in men’s prison

3:00

 

 

Larry Turner, math teacher and father of a murder victim

3:10

 

 

Rev. Paul Robeson Ford, Union Baptist Church

3:15

 

 

Donnelle Wright, Jobs Not Jails

3:20

 

 

Candidates for Attorney General (Warren Tolman confirmed)

3:40

 

 

MUSIC 

 

 

According to Steve O’Neil, executive director of Ex-Prisoners and Prisoners Organizing for Community Advancement (EPOCA), the idea of JNJ came about after many across the state fought against Three Strikes legislation in 2012. O’Neill wanted to build on that groundswell and said in an interview that it was “a realization that for deep-seated change to occur in the criminal justice system, more coalition and leadership building were needed.” He added that “It is not just about flaws in CJ system…It is also about the hollowing out of labor in our economy—We are not even doing job training anymore,” and  it is especially difficult for those with criminal records to get jobs, he said.

On their website Jobs Not Jails lists some initial and far-reaching goals of the campaign against mass incarceration:

Cassandra Bensahih, a Community Organizer for EPOCA, and MC for the day of the rally, is a former prisoner who describes herself as “hooked” on the way EPOCA does organizing. She appreciates the second chance they gave her and has spoken all across the state to get signatures and raise awareness. She said in an interview she feels the current Jobs Not Jails campaign is a significant part of a movement to end mass incarceration because “it addresses racism and poverty and looks at legislative reform.” For her, it’s important for her kids to have a better life; she is particularly interested in diversion to treatment for drug offenders instead of jail.

While there are more than 100 organizations which have signed on as supporters of JNJ, an active group also fighting for job creation is the Youth Jobs Coalition (YJC), with branches in Worcester, Brockton, and Boston. Founded by Dan Gelbtuch, YJC is a coalition of 40 youth and community groups from across the state which work together to create more employment opportunities for teens—especially difficult in a sagging economy.

Keturah Brewster, a senior at Boston Latin and lead organizer for YJC who will speak at the rally has been tirelessly collecting signatures on JNJ petitions. She experienced racial discrimination when she and her friends were just hanging out harmlessly in Boston. She described, in an interview, how police officers ambushed three of her male friends and beat up one, and watched as they were whisked away to jail; one was accused of assaulting an officer. She is worried about the racial issues in incarceration. Likewise, Devens Archer, another YJC activist is concerned about incarceration of youth, and also about job opportunities after prison. He said he’s trying to collect 1000 signatures.

O’Neill said that many legislators think their constituents are uneducated and maybe even unconcerned about these issues, but “They’re wrong.” Each person who shows up or signs a petition, he said, demonstrates the strength people have to lobby for change and demand public spending to create jobs rather than prison cells.

For more on JNJ thoughts on job creation, see here, and come to the rally on April 26!

Appalachian Prisons and Beyond

This weekend I went to West Virginia with many education in prison folks from around the country to the Educational Justice and Appalachia Prisons Symposium.

Morgantown, West Virginia is a cross between a college town and scenes from A Coal Miner’s Daughter. It’s only 1 and 1/2 hours from Pittsburgh but a lot of rolling hills until you hit the city. The speakers were stellar, each adding something unique to the event. But I couldn’t stop singing “Country Roads, Take Me Home” all weekend.

The first panel with incarcerated Inside Out students was accompanied by an officer to the presentation where presenters talked about their lives, and writing while locked in a federal prison. Inside Out in WVA brings college students inside in a unique program that offers college credit to both inside and outside students, Some comments from prisoners who were in attendance: “Without the outside, us on the inside would just be talking to ourselves;” and “Not writing about mass incarceration today would be like not writing about slavery in the 19th century.” Anne Rice, a powerhouse who teaches in a prison program with Lehman University, and has coordinated TEDx talks inside prisons, was also on that panel. She reinforced recent RAND Report findings–higher ed reduces recidivism. Also raised in this panel were two important concerns: some students of color don’t want to be in Inside-out programs because they don’t want to be any nearer than they are to the CJ system. And there can be a stigma associated with doing programs.

How hard it is to get past your past with social media continuing to scarlet letter you, I thought, as audience members rightly talked about how we need to find jobs for kids coming out of the system, fix the system and not-so-much, the kids. And I thought again of what Angela Davis said recently in a talk at Babson College which knocked my socks off: “Prisons are havens for outdated ideologies.”

The next panel included Jim Rubenstein, the Commissioner of Corrections in West Virginia, who shocked me when he said West Virginia has the 4th lowest recidivism rate in the country at 27%. Why, I wondered? Do they have such long sentences that no one gets out? Considering that Massachusetts’ recidivism is closer to 60% I want to try and understand his data. The Commissioner also spoke of drug addiction and incarceration. When I spoke on Changing Lives Through Literature, I said, in response to the first two panels, that we should take the word “inmate” out of our conversation, and that we should approach drug addiction as a health problem not as a criminal justice issue (See The House I Live in). Then I spoke about the program I love that has graduated more than 5000 probationers nation-wide.

The evening was highlighted by Rebecca Ginsburg’s stunning program, Education Justice Project, which is very collaborative with people inside/outside. It is a model college-in-prison-program, and the keys are: critical pedagogy, involvement of families, and starting slowly. One of my favorite things that Ginsburg said is that the program is “about the quality of life for anyone wherever they stand.” It is not just about recidivism, or re-entry. She highlighted that at the Higher Education in Prison conference in October, 2014, prisoners will be presenters as well as scholars from the outside.

Restorative Justice (RJ) was one of the highlights of the next day. Attorney Brenda Waugh said RJ depends on humility, respect and wonder, and the central issue is to “address harm.” Victims meet with those they have harmed, and although forgiveness is not always possible, some kind of understanding is. Judge Michael Aloi said entering a courtroom is “entering intense suffering.” He talked about “restoring dignity” to people, expungement of records, and being a non-judgmental judge. Attorney Valeena Beety, who teaches at the WVA Law School, quoted Angela Davis by saying that “prison is an abstract site into which people are placed,” and it is supposedly justified by the fact that it incapacitates. Most impressive at this panel was Jacqueline Roebuck Sakho who brought her small children, asked permission of the elders in the room before she spoke, and said we cannot do restorative justice until we confront multiple narratives of the system, who is responsible for crime, and who or what is actually guiltyBkjFmc4CYAEigfK.

 

 

Brenda Waugh, Judge Aoli, and Jackie Sakho.

Kyes Stevens shocked me with this: Alabama prisons are 198% overcrowded. Stevens worked at Tutweiller Prison where abuse is rampant, she said, and then “In steps poetry.” The Alabama Prison Arts & Education Project is thriving with many sites throughout the state and many teachers. Stevens finds joy in her work in prison, knows how to bring in all the stakeholders, and my favorite comment from her: “A handful of pencils” can lead to “amazing art.”

Both the Appalachian Book Project and Books Through Bars in Philadelphia do the incredible hard work of getting books to prisoners, both in West Virginia (ABP), and up and down the east coast (BTB). Marc Niesen from Chatham University in Pittsburgh mentioned the epiphany we all have who teach/have taught inside: “I can walk out.” The Chatham program has a great resource and a video on their site with the concept that words help you get outside your cell. On that same panel was Laura Leigh Morris who teaches in a Texas prison where women say they want the writing class to be a “refuge.” Most interesting, she said, “I have to pee in a cup to teach there.” Oh Texas!

The final presentation of the weekend was Dwayne Betts, poet, former prisoner and now student at Yale Law School. He shared his experience behind bars growing into  books and words. He read from his books of poetry and I am now devouring his memoir, A Question of Freedom. What an amazing mind. I’ll leave you with a snippet from one of his poems, entitled, “A Post-Modern Two Step:”

And this is ruin. Damn these chains,
this awkward dance I do with this van. Two-step,
my body swaying back and forth, my head
a pendulum that’s rocked by the wild riffs
of the dudes I’m riding with: them white folks know
you ain’t god body, what you commune wine
and bread? Where you from son? Red lines?
To what Onion? My eyes two caskets though,
so the voices are sheets of sound. Our van as dark
inside as out, and all the bodies black
and voices black too and I tell my god
if you have ears for this one, know I want
no part of it, no Onions and no tears.
I tell no one, and cry my dirge.
This place,
the cracked and scratching vinyl seats, the loud
loud talk of murder this and blanket fear
around the rest, is where I’m most at home,
but it’s beyond where prayers reach, a point
something like purgatory. I lean back
and drift in sleep as someone says, his voice
all hoarse and jacked, all broken songbird-like
all revolutions end with a L-note.

What a weekend.